Showing posts with label fandom. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fandom. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 9, 2011

Art, imitating life

I used to have this HUGE thing for Jason Robert Brown's music, and today I was searching my iPod for songs to listen to while traveling to community, and I thought of him. I googled him again and found this strangely appropriate paragraph, which is apparently how he rephrased something that Stephen Sondheim said to him:
Nobody cares what you think. Once a creation has been put into the world, you have only one responsibility to its creator: Be supportive. Support is not about showing how clever you are, how observant of some flaw, how incisive in your criticism. There are other people whose job it is to guide the creation, to make it work, to make it live; either they did their job or they didn't. But that is not your problem. If you come to my show and you see me afterwords, say only this: "I loved it". It doesn't matter if that's what you really felt. What I need at that moment is to know that you care enough about me and the work I do to tell me that you loved it, not "in spite of its flaws", not "even though everyone else seems to have a problem with it", but simply, plainly, "I loved it." If you can't say that, don't come backstage, don't find me in the lobby, don't lean over the pit to see me. Just go home, and either write me a nice email or don't. Say all the catty, bitchy things you want to your friend, your neighbor, the Internet. Maybe next week, maybe next year, maybe someday down the line, I'll be ready to hear what you have to say, but at that moment, that face-to-face moment after I have unveiled some part of my soul, however small, to you:that is the most vulnerable moment in any artist's life. I beg you, plead with you to tell me what you really thought, what you actually, honestly, totally believed, then you must tell me "I loved it." That moment must be respected."


And the thing is, that really surprised me. I've always thought of Sondheim as a really tough guy, who just puts his art out there regardless of what people think of it. (And through the years, despite his genius, there have been some pretty mixed responses.) But I think that was wrong of me, and that I missed something that is so integral to his work: that it is all so intensely personal. (And I think I missed a huge chunk of what "Sunday in the Park with George" was all about! Now, despite myself, I think I understand it better.) Whether it's good art or bad art, or good musical theatre or bad musical theatre, whenever I pop a CD of his into a player (or a CD of Jason Robert Brown's, for that matter), I am actually listening to pieces of a man's soul, put to music. Interspersed, too, with the art and soul (haha.) of the people who sang his songs, the musicians who played the notes.

I know that my little story--my 13,999 word story that took so long to write but still ended up underdeveloped and a little awful--is nothing to Sondheim's immortal work, and that ten years from now the fifty people or so who have read it will probably have forgotten all about it, but it is still a part of my soul, and I hope that when it's revealed people will be... nice to me. Nice enough. Nice enough to tell me, "I loved it."

Wednesday, July 13, 2011

Once in a lifetime

I find myself almost unbearably affected by all this fuss about the last HP film. It shouldn't matter to me in the least, because honestly I was never able to suspend disbelief long enough to believe that Dan Radcliffe was Harry, or even that Alan Rickman was Severus Snape. (It's a little different with Emma Watson. As much as I disliked her from the very beginning, there was something about how she portrayed Hermione Granger in the two most recent films. I could almost believe that the same Hermione I've been dreaming and writing and thinking about for the last eleven years was her, in Burberry plaid, dancing with Harry in a sad tent.)

So I guess it shouldn't matter. Unfortunately it does. I've stayed away from fan communities and livejournal in an attempt to keep studying for exams and to keep my head down until all the fuss was over--which is basically the same thing I did when DH came around--but with everyone in my class discussing it and with my Facebook feed spilling over with mournful status messages and meaningful, tear-jearking pictures of the actors and of fanart, it's hard to get away from it all.

I know that this is an unrepeatable point in history. Harry Potter, despite what my theatre teacher and my Uncle Johnny used to say, is going to live on forever. It will perhaps be even bigger, on the scale of eternity, than Lord of the Rings or that most adapted, most fanficced creation, Sherlock Holmes. I know that this will never happen again. People from future generations will wonder what it was like to stand in line for the first Harry Potter movie, or the last.

And I don't really want to miss it, but at the same time I do; I get irrationally, unbearably affected when it comes to things fictional and fannish. About a month ago I spent a whole night crying miserably while my mom fussed over me, just because I kept thinking what it would mean if SNUFF came out and it's Terry Pratchett's last book, because he might die/never write one again/both. I couldn't stop crying over the last Harry Potter book, too--I hid from it for as long as I was able, read through it quickly so it would be less painful (in the old rip-off-the-band-aid stratagem), and never touched it again. I'm not ready for big emotional upheavals; I've never been good at dealing with them. I can't study and can't sleep, and eat too much, and I just can't even. I cried for two whole days about Severus Snape back in college, when I found out (through some unwelcome spoilery) that he was going to die.

And now I'm twenty two years old and I still feel the same way, if not more intensely, more tenderly.

And the thing is, what does this say about me and the culture I've been moving around in? Is it still abnormal to get so worked up about fictional things? Given this milieu, what is abnormal, what is maladjusted? Is this on the same level as that three year old on Jay Leno who was crying, without reason, about Justin Bieber?

I don't really understand. Without Severus Snape it might have just been one more children's story. But it wasn't, because he was there, a silent figure, more real than anyone I've ever read about--more beloved, more true to himself. Although, if you think about it, almost everything he did was behind the scenes--taking a backseat, it seemed to me, to balls and parties and butterbeer and all those things that were Harry. I shouldn't have fallen in love with him, but I did.

I know that half of the world can probably relate to the dark mess that is my feelings--I know that a lot of us are crying. And I know that a lot of us who have invested so much of our lives in fic and in actively participating in this fandom, in not just being passive receivers of something wonderful, are both dizzyingly happy to be a part of it, and devastated that somehow it's an end of something. Which is probably irrational because it's going to be there forever anyway.

I think this is called mourning.

Wednesday, August 11, 2010

Always 1895

Sherlock Holmes is so huge and at the same time so much a part of my life, of my very identity (my email address of about twelve years is based on the number of steps to the door of 221B Baker Street, his legendary home. Beat that), that I find it hard to write about him. There is too much of myself that I've invested.

I've been pretty much an "alone" fan since I was little. I had friends online who liked Sherlock Holmes--I joined the very first Discussion Group on the Yahoo! Groups website (HOUNDS-L, in case you're wondering. It's still alive, and our old discussions are still there!), and wrote and discussed and dreamed and analyzed and memorized like everyone else. I played THE GAME like everyone else, and if you don't know what the Game is, it would be wonderful for you to find out. ...But while the fandom is dynamic, the canon itself, in the nature of canon, has always been static. It's always the same stories, the same gas lights, the same speculations.

So even though I didn't expect or want it, this sudden surge of Sherlock Holmes-related things in the media--the film starring Robert Downey Jr, the other slightly-silly British film of the same year that piggy-backed on the Hollywood film's fame, and this new, incredible, breathtaking series SHERLOCK--has made things... different. More alive. Has given us more fanon to talk about, circling around the canon, being irreverent to it, being faithful to it in all of ways that actually matter. More and more people are being drawn into reading the original stories. And purists, as purists often are, are wary of these new shows, but are secretly happy to know more than everyone else about Sherlock Holmes, and to get the jokes--the five orange pips, RACHE(L), the Bruce Partington Plans and Cadogan West, Mycroft Holmes gaining "a little weight"... And the fact that Sherlock is called "Sherlock", rather than Holmes, because there was only one real, definitive Holmes on screen, and he died in 1995. And he was as faithful to the canon as anybody could have been, and this new, beautiful series respects that.

I should know. I'm a purist, and I always have been (my forays into Mary Russell fanfiction notwithstanding).

But even I can see this: SHERLOCK has done what nothing else has been able to do since Jeremy Brett: to bring him to life.

And to bring us hounds, all over the world, closer together.

The Game is on, and we will be waiting.

Saturday, August 7, 2010

Not faint canaries, but ambrosial


Here, then, at home, by no more storms distrest,
Folding laborious hands we sit, wings furled;
Here in close perfume lies the rose-leaf curled,
Here the sun stands and knows not east nor west,
Here no tide runs; we have come, last and best,
From the wide zone through dizzying circles hurled,
To that still centre where the spinning world
Sleeps on its axis, to the heart of rest.

Lay on thy whips, O Love, that we upright,
Poised on the perilous point, in no lax bed
May sleep, as tension at the verberant core
Of music sleeps; for, if thou spare to smite,
Staggering, we stoop, stooping, fall dumb and dead,
And, dying, so, sleep our sweet sleep no more.

-Dorothy Sayers, Gaudy Night


Lord and Lady Peter, I know you are somewhere loving and being loved. I have never met anyone in real life who loves you as much as I do, and I am still waiting for that day that I will say, "Placetne, magistra?" and someone will say, "Placet."

When that day comes, I'll make a pilgrimage to Dorothy L Sayers' grave and thank her.

Monday, July 19, 2010

Monday yet again


If I could live in a book, I would probably live in Anne of Green Gables/Avonlea/the Island. I've been rereading and rewatching Anne this weekend, following the harrowing experience of my second pharmacology exam. If I lived in that world there would be exams too, but there would also be green, expansive fields, cooperative animals in Patty's Place, and dresses. Rather that, than this dreary city existence with dirty rainy streets and flash floods and wet shoes and spotted white uniforms. And of course, if I lived in that world, I could exclaim (like I wanted to yesterday) "But it oughtn't to rain on a Sunday!" and I would have been met with a chorus of agreement.

I don't know what's wrong. In medicine it's called a prodrome--there are signs and symptoms of something wrong, but you don't know what it is. Oh well. I suppose I'll be able to tell pretty soon. Meanwhile, a barrage of exams--one to three every week, for mercy's sake--still await me.

To end with a lighthearted anecdote: I was on the same bus as a childhood love this morning. I don't think he noticed me--my bespectacled head was buried quite deeply into the disreputable copy of Anne of the Island that I bought from a booksale last Friday, with Ado's money--but I tried to hide all the same. If only all childhood loves could turn out like Gilbert and Anne! In this case I rather suspect I was the Charlie Sloane and he the Anne Shirley.